Why Fragrance Allergen Labeling Matters
Fragrance allergies affect millions of Europeans, with contact allergy to fragrance ingredients being one of the most common causes of cosmetic-related adverse reactions. According to EU Regulation 1223/2009, certain fragrance allergens must be individually labeled on cosmetic products to enable sensitive consumers to avoid them.
Major Changes Coming
Fragrance allergen labeling serves multiple purposes:
- Consumer protection — Enabling informed choice for sensitive individuals
- Medical diagnosis — Helping identify allergens responsible for reactions
- Product development — Encouraging reformulation to reduce sensitization
- Transparency — Providing ingredient information beyond "parfum/fragrance"
Legal Basis: Article 19 and Annex III
Article 19: Labeling Requirements
Article 19 of Regulation 1223/2009 establishes general labeling requirements, including that certain substances must be listed by specific INCI name rather than grouped under "parfum" or "aroma."
Article 19 Allergen Labeling Requirements
- Allergens must appear in the ingredient list by INCI name
- Position follows normal descending order by concentration
- Thresholds differ for leave-on vs. rinse-off products
- Applies regardless of whether allergen is added intentionally or is part of fragrance compound
- Natural extract-derived allergens must also be declared
Annex III: Restricted Substances
Annex III lists fragrance allergens with mandatory labeling requirements. Entries 45-111 specifically cover fragrance allergens with concentration thresholds.
Regulation 2023/1545: The Expansion
Commission Regulation (EU) 2023/1545 dramatically expands allergen labeling based on updated scientific evidence from the SCCS.
What Changed?
| Aspect | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Number of declarable allergens | 26 substances | 80+ substances |
| Categories of allergens | Individual synthetic substances mostly | Includes natural-derived, pre-haptens, pro-haptens |
| Scientific basis | SCCS 1999 opinion | SCCS 2012 opinion + updates |
| Natural extract coverage | Limited | Expanded with specific allergen declarations |
Transition Timeline
Two Distinct Compliance Deadlines
| Product Status | Deadline | Requirement |
|---|---|---|
| NEW products | July 31, 2026 | Products newly PLACED ON the EU market must comply with expanded allergen labeling |
| EXISTING products | July 31, 2028 | Products already on shelves must be withdrawn if non-compliant |
* 'Placed on market' = first made available in EU (manufacturer/importer action)
* 'Made available' = any subsequent distribution (retailer sales)
The 80+ Allergen List
The expanded allergen list includes several categories:
Original 26 Allergens (Already Required)
| INCI Name | CAS Number | Common Source |
|---|---|---|
| Amyl cinnamal | 122-40-7 | Synthetic |
| Benzyl alcohol | 100-51-6 | Natural/Synthetic |
| Cinnamyl alcohol | 104-54-1 | Cinnamon oil |
| Citral | 5392-40-5 | Lemon oil, lemongrass |
| Eugenol | 97-53-0 | Clove oil |
| Hydroxycitronellal | 107-75-5 | Synthetic |
| Isoeugenol | 97-54-1 | Ylang ylang |
| Amylcinnamyl alcohol | 101-85-9 | Synthetic |
| Benzyl salicylate | 118-58-1 | Synthetic |
| Cinnamal | 104-55-2 | Cinnamon |
| Coumarin | 91-64-5 | Tonka bean, lavender |
| Geraniol | 106-24-1 | Rose oil, geranium |
| Hydroxyisohexyl 3-cyclohexene carboxaldehyde (HICC) | 31906-04-4 | Synthetic (now banned) |
| Anise alcohol | 105-13-5 | Anise |
| Benzyl cinnamate | 103-41-3 | Synthetic |
| Farnesol | 4602-84-0 | Many essential oils |
| Butylphenyl methylpropional (Lilial) | 80-54-6 | Synthetic (now banned) |
| Linalool | 78-70-6 | Lavender, rosewood |
| Benzyl benzoate | 120-51-4 | Peru balsam |
| Citronellol | 106-22-9 | Rose, geranium |
| Hexyl cinnamal | 101-86-0 | Chamomile |
| Limonene | 5989-27-5 | Citrus oils |
| Methyl 2-octynoate | 111-12-6 | Synthetic |
| Alpha-isomethyl ionone | 127-51-5 | Synthetic |
| Evernia prunastri (oakmoss) extract | 90028-68-5 | Natural |
| Evernia furfuracea (treemoss) extract | 90028-67-4 | Natural |
Newly Added Allergens (Post-2023/1545)
| INCI Name | CAS Number | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Atranol | 526-37-4 | Oakmoss constituent |
| Chloroatranol | 57074-21-2 | Oakmoss constituent |
| Methyl salicylate | 119-36-8 | Wintergreen oil |
| Salicylaldehyde | 90-02-8 | Bitter almond |
| Carvone | 99-49-0 | Spearmint, caraway |
| Citrus aurantium amara oil | Various | Bitter orange |
| Laurus nobilis oil | 8007-48-5 | Bay laurel |
| Mentha piperita oil | 8006-90-4 | Peppermint |
| Eugenia caryophyllus oil | 8000-34-8 | Clove |
| Cinnamomum cassia oil | 8007-80-5 | Cassia/cinnamon |
Concentration Thresholds
Leave-On vs. Rinse-Off
Labeling is required only when allergen concentration exceeds specified thresholds:
| Product Type | Threshold | Rationale |
|---|---|---|
| Leave-on products | 0.001% (10 ppm) | Prolonged skin contact increases sensitization risk |
| Rinse-off products | 0.01% (100 ppm) | Shorter contact reduces exposure |
Threshold Calculation
Calculation Example
Example Calculation
Grouped Allergen Threshold Calculation
The regulation introduces a "grouped allergen" approach for certain substances that are chemically related or cross-sensitizing:
| Type | Definition | Threshold Calculation |
|---|---|---|
| Standalone allergen | One substance = one label name | Label if individual concentration exceeds threshold |
| Grouped allergens | Multiple cross-sensitizing substances = one 'Group Name' | Sum ALL group member concentrations — label if TOTAL exceeds threshold |
Important: Grouped Allergen Summation
Natural Extract Allergens
Natural extracts present special challenges because they contain multiple allergens simultaneously.
How to Handle Natural Extracts
Allergen Declaration for Natural Extracts
Obtain Allergen Declaration from Supplier
Request quantitative allergen content for all 80+ declarable substances present in the extract.
Calculate Finished Product Concentration
Multiply extract allergen content by usage level in finished product.
Compare to Thresholds
Check each allergen against 0.001% (leave-on) or 0.01% (rinse-off) thresholds.
List All Above-Threshold Allergens
Include all allergens exceeding thresholds in the ingredient list by INCI name.
Common High-Allergen Natural Ingredients
| Essential Oil | Major Allergens | Typical Allergen Content |
|---|---|---|
| Lavender (Lavandula angustifolia) | Linalool, linalyl acetate, limonene | 30-50% linalool |
| Rose (Rosa damascena) | Citronellol, geraniol, linalool | 15-40% citronellol |
| Lemon (Citrus limon) | Limonene, citral | 60-80% limonene |
| Cinnamon bark (Cinnamomum cassia) | Cinnamal, eugenol, coumarin | 70-90% cinnamal |
| Ylang ylang (Cananga odorata) | Linalool, benzyl benzoate, geraniol | 15-40% linalool |
| Tea tree (Melaleuca alternifolia) | Limonene, linalool | 1-5% limonene |
Pre-Haptens and Pro-Haptens
SCCS guidance addresses substances that are not directly allergenic but convert to allergens:
| Type | Definition | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-hapten | Converts to allergen via air oxidation | Limonene → limonene hydroperoxides |
| Pro-hapten | Converts to allergen via skin metabolism | Isoeugenol → metabolic reactive species |
Oxidation Products
Labeling Requirements: INCI Names
Allergens must be listed by their correct INCI name as defined in Article 33 and the CosIng database.
Correct Labeling Format
Allergen Labeling Best Practices
- Use exact INCI names from CosIng database
- Position in ingredient list by concentration (descending order)
- May appear after 'parfum' if concentration is <1%
- Capitalization follows standard INCI conventions
- No abbreviations unless officially recognized
- Natural extracts: list both extract name AND individual allergens
Example Ingredient List
Example Compliant Labeling
CPSR & PIF Updates Required
The safety assessment must address allergen presence:
CPSR Requirements for Allergens
- Document all allergens present in formula (quantitative)
- Include allergen declarations from fragrance/flavor suppliers
- Assess sensitization risk for high-concentration allergens
- Document threshold calculations for labeling decisions
- Update if fragrance composition changes
Impact on Product Development
Reformulation Considerations
| Strategy | Approach | Considerations |
|---|---|---|
| Reduce fragrance level | Lower overall perfume concentration | May affect consumer appeal |
| Switch to low-allergen fragrances | Use fragrances with fewer declarable allergens | Limits creative palette |
| Synthetic alternatives | Replace natural extracts with targeted synthetics | Consumer perception of 'natural' |
| Encapsulation | Reduce direct skin contact with allergens | Technical complexity, cost |
| Fragrance-free | Eliminate perfume entirely | Some consumers prefer fragrance |